| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Searn |
Who do you like in D3 for 2009? |
Lead | ||
|
Final 8 in 08 = automatic bid
Who do you like in D3 for 2009? (Total Votes: 37) - ClosedAdrian (1 / 2.7%) Bay City John Glenn (0 / 0%) Bloomfield Hills Lahser (3 / 8.1%) Carleton Airport (0 / 0%) Chelsea (1 / 2.7%) DeWitt (3 / 8.1%) East Grand Rapids (17 / 45.9%) East Lansing (0 / 0%) Mt. Pleasant (0 / 0%) Orchard Lake St. Mary (6 / 16.2%) Stevensville Lakeshore (1 / 2.7%) St. Joseph (4 / 10.8%) Warren Fitzgerald (1 / 2.7%) Other - Please List if you vote OTHER (0 / 0%) |
||||
|
|
||||
HS Footballer |
#1 | |||
|
Just curious, why the * after DeWitt?
|
||||
|
|
||||
Searn |
#2 | |||
HS Footballer wrote: Because you just gave away who you voted for. .....
After you vote it will show the * next to who you voted for. |
||||
|
|
||||
HS Footballer |
#3 | |||
|
No problem with my vote. I live in the Mid Michigan Area and from what I am hearing on the sports talk radio, TV and the LSJ, DeWitt baring injuries should be
very solid and a contender. They have size speed, experience and a very good kicking game. They also have depth and a great work ethic. Anything can happen,
but I think DeWitt will be a factor this year. Hope I don't jinx then.
|
||||
|
|
||||
completehomer |
#4 | |||
|
OK, those not voting for EGR, is the rationale that you think they'll be in a division other than 3?
Just kidding, but it's hard to pick against that program until they show some sign of weakness. |
||||
|
|
||||
Searn |
#5 | |||
|
I agree it's tough to pick against EGR at this rate ... They seem to be on their own level in D3 ....
We should find out week 1 if one if OLSM has the stuff to compete with EGR like they did 2 years ago at Ford Field .... But even if OLSM takes EGR to the limit and loses say 24-21 ... It could still be a tossup whether OLSM even makes the playoffs Vote for 2009 MHSAA Football Conference Winners New Conference Polls to be added daily this summer. Vote on who you like for the 2009 State Championships in Division 1, Division 2, Division 3, .... more to come... |
||||
|
|
||||
prepseer |
OLSM | #6 | ||
Searn wrote:Even with that embarrassing game against Melvindale Academy of Business and Technology in Week Three, it doesn't look good for OLSM's playoff chances. |
||||
|
|
||||
cheeks33 |
#7 | |||
|
Just curious, who does EGR have returning from last years team? I know they lost their stud running back and I think they lost their stud TE/DE from last
year. Who else do they have that will be making an impact on this years team?
|
||||
|
|
||||
FBR2 |
#8 | |||
|
They always have players to make an impact. I'm going to take the chance right now and go out on a line and declare that EGR will not win D3 this year.
Someone will get a lucky break against them and knock them off. Of course I think I'm partially crazy for even suggesting EGR loses, but someone is bound
to beat them in the playoffs at some point and this year I think will be the best chance someone (anyone) has. I'd go as far as to predict Mt.
Pleasant/Lakeshore/St. Joe/OLSM will be the team to knock them out this year. I'd toss Chelsea/Dewitt/Adrian in, but they haven't advanced far in the
playoffs in the last several years, so I don't know enough about them to make such a wild guess as I already have made. The only reason I would pick the
four teams above is because they'll have playoff experience already and it just takes one good game to move on to the next round. But i say this all with
the notion in mind that I am most likely wrong and EGR will win the next several champions uncontested.
|
||||
|
|
||||
EastGuRu |
#9 | |||
|
EGR impact/skill position players this year: Josh Drummond (RB/FB/DB), Voss brothers Colin and Trent (TE, RB, DE, LB), AJ McEwen (WR, QB, DB), Ryan Elble (QB
likely), Kirk Spencer, (RB, DB). There may be others coming up from JV that will have an impact but these are the "for sure's" barring injury.
No superstars like Glendenning's or Grady's but all very good players, all with shots at being All Metro GR players. Interestingly, there is one more Grady in the pipeline and he will be a Soph this year. Don't know if he will make the move up or not. Good athlete that saw significant PT on Varsity Basketball so it is very possible that Stuursma will bring him up. As far as EGR getting knocked off...certainly anything is possible. EGR's run will end sometime. No one stays on top forever. After last years drubbing, I can't really get my mind around a Mt. Pleasant or Bay City Glenn pulling some kind of upset. Those teams had pretty good seasons last year and they were not on the same level by a mile. Nor any teams from the North (Gaylord, Cadillac, etc.). I could see Stevensville Lakeshore doing it. They have had enough shots at us that they are no longer awestruck. Maybe St. Joe - ditto above. Chelsea, maybe DeWitt, they will both likely have some firepower that could make a win possible. As far as OLSM....I don't know what to think. Bolden is scary but to listen to others on this board, they may not have much else. Last years OLSM JV did not show much against the EGR JV that's for sure. I guess we'll find out week one. EGR will be solid this year and probably next but it will NOT be a foregone conclusion that they make it back to Ford Field. BTW, to all the Lakeshore and St. Joe players and alum... don't take the "awestruck" comment wrong. I don't think any of your players played scared. All of those games were hard fought and you guys were very good. But, there is a certain amount of human nature in all of us and the difference between winning and losing is sometimes razor thin and can hinge on just a few intangibles. East's playoff history is to some degree their twelfth man. Between the overwhelming confidence it breeds in the young players minds and the always denied, but still real, intimidation factor of all those titles, it gives them that little edge in big contests that usually leaves the winner saying "I knew we would" and the loser saying, "dang, we almost had 'em". Both Lakeshore and St. Joe have had enough shots at us now that I don't think that edge exists (it's been long gone with Lowell for example). That's why I could see either of those teams beating East this year.
Last Edited By: EastGuRu 07/08/09 11:06 PM.
Edited 2 times.
|
||||
|
|
||||
SnoozeToMe |
#10 | |||
|
Good post, EastGuRu.
One might choose "the field" over EGR this year (or any year for that matter). But if you have to pick just one favorite, it would be hard to pick anyone else. |
||||
|
|
||||
FBR2 |
#11 | |||
|
EastGuRu I think you hit the nail on the head. I agree with you also 100% on the "awestruck" comment. When playing EGR, you just come in with a
mental barrier that you have to overcome. I'd be surprised if a first time (playing EGR) team came in and just knocked them down. I'd like to just
through out there though that I put Mt. Pleasant on my short list of possible upsetters BECAUSE of the the last two years in which they've been blown out
by EGR in the playoffs. Now, if I was a betting man I'd pick St. Joe/Lakeshore/OLSM to be the team to upset EGR well over Mt. Pleasant but there's just
something in me that's saying that they have to want to get revenge on those embarrassing loses and if utilized well, it could be enough to pull an upset.
I hope no Mt. Pleasant fans/alumni take offense to what I've said, I just wanted to make my slim case for them.
|
||||
|
|
||||
prepseer |
East GuRu | #12 | ||
|
Agree. That was a good post East GuRu. Well-written and well thought-out. As for the "awestruck" comment, I agree it can be an important
intangible. I've seen it before in Brother Rice games. I think it was a factor last year in the opener vs Oak Park, although as it turned out, OP was
grossly overrated. It has helped Brother Rice in games they used to play in Week One at the Silverdome vs some pretty good teams who were not used to
playing at the Dome. Rice rarely lost those games even though they were playing teams that were arguably better. It usually took a half or so before those
good teams got rid of the intimidation factor and played up to their abilities. That was often too late.
Thanks for the scouting report on EGR. I don't know any of those names you mentioned, but I assume you have some knowledge of their ability. I'll take a wait-and-see approach. I still suspect that Glendenning will not be that easy to replace and East will not be as good as last year. Good programs do know how to reload, however, and East is a good program. Interesting to hear there's another Grady in the wings. Am I right in assumming that it may be another year before he has a real impact. This could be the year for someone else to emerge victorius at Ford Field. |
||||
|
|
||||
darin harvey |
#13 | |||
|
I like Chelsea vs EGR in the finals.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Papa Bear |
#14 | |||
|
Voted for East GR. Is there anyone else? Until someone knocks them off, or shows me something otherwise, they have got to be the heavy favorite to make it 4
in a row.
|
||||
|
|
||||
HS Footballer |
#15 | |||
|
I am still in DeWitt's camp. They will surprise a lot of people.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Quick Links